Romney, In His Own Words: "The People Who Need The Help Most Are Not The Poor"
By Bill Scher
October 25, 2011 - 11:37am ET
Popular This Week
Also Worth Reading
If you were waiting for an economic plan from presidential candidate Mitt Romney that helps the poor, you might be waiting for a while.
Stumping in Iowa last Thursday, Romney explicitly stated that helping the poor need not be a top priority -- "In our country, the people who need the help most are not the poor..."
Why does Romney think the poor do not need the most help? Here's the full quote:
"In our country, the people who need the help most are not the poor, who have a safety net, not the rich, who are doing just fine, but the middle class."
The class warfare double-edged wedge. Pretty slick Mitt.
He avoids the rhetorical trap that many of his fellow Republicans fall into, suggesting the rich don't need help instead of whining that they are the ones under assault. (Left unsaid by Romney is that he still supports more tax giveaways to the wealthy: keeping the Bush tax cuts, cutting corporate taxes and abolishing the estate tax for multimillionaire heirs.)
He expresses sympathy to the middle class, which is how most of us see ourselves, and pledges to relieve their burden.
But mainly, he tries to drive a wedge between the middle class and the poor, goading the middle class into being resentful of the poor for coasting on a golden "safety net" while the rest of us scrape to get by.
While it's nice that Romney appears to tacitly recognize that America would be far worse if we turned the clock back 80 years and threw out federal programs that provide health care, food assistance and financial aid to the poor, let's get real. These programs don't even cover everyone under the poverty line (a mere $22,350 for a family of four), let alone those technically over the poverty line who still struggle.
For example, nearly 50 million Americans experienced food insecurity last year, meaning they were unsure how they were going afford their next meal, often forcing them to eat less healthy food and for 11 million of those, some times less food period.
We can be thankful that thanks to liberal public policy, we now have federal aid so most poor people do not literally starve. But avoiding mass starvation is a pretty low bar.
Fortunately, these sorts of conservative class warfare tactics – much like the cruder "We Are The 53%" mantra disparaging poor and middle class workers who do not earn enough to pay net federal income taxes -- do not seem to be turning the public against aiding those in need. In this month's CNN poll, 60% supported "increasing federal aid to unemployed workers" and 76% supported "increasing the taxes paid by people who make more than one million dollars a year."
Such poll numbers should not be surprising. There have been many news reports about the plight of the jobless because of the Great Recession. There have not been many news reports about former millionaires who lost it all because of the Great Recession. Everyone knows that Wall Street got bailed out. Few believe that the poor got the same deal.
But apparently, Mitt Romney is one who does.
Help us spread the word about these important stories...
Email to a friend
Views expressed on this page are those of the authors and not necessarily those of Campaign for America's Future or Institute for America's Future